Well......I found another Baby Ruth in the punch bowl on my Jeep Salad Bar today. (Yes, metaphor mixology is one of my other hobbies). And I thought I'd get back to posting on my project page instead of the Tech Knowledge Base - been lazy about that.
To re-cap, the truck was converted to 12v by previous owner. My 1st jeep (still a rookie), and I always thought the starter turned the engine over pretty well (even if it wouldn't run due to other issues -- all now repaired). No grinding noises, but what the heck do I know? About once in 20-25 attempts the Bendix would spin out but not engage the flywheel. Not a huge problem me thinks (but obviously not right) and it came up on the list for a look today. So, I pulled the starter motor to see what I have. Although I knew I have an early bell housing and starter, I was never certain of the tooth count on the flywheel and starter pinion gear. Now I am.........flywheel is 97-tooth........starter pinion gear is 9-tooth......what? Count them both again. Count was accurate the first time. I learned from Wes here that 97-tooth flywheel goes with 10-tooth pinion gear not 9. The Willys Service Manual is about as clear as mud on this --- too many variables I guess.
I don't have any busted or chipped gear teeth (lucky I guess, or a testimony to a rugged design?) How in the heck could it crank so well?
I cleaned a handful of crud out of the brush end of the motor, and I think the brushes are wearing thin, no doubt a re-build was in my future anyway. But this thing works!
No way to tell what it is...... a 6-volt MZ-4113 with the wrong bendix drive on it? A MZ-4113 re-wound for 12v and a bendix for a 124-tooth flywheel? MZ-4163 ? Possibilities abound, and wondering doesn't get me where I need to go.
The flywheel looks so good (I looked at every tooth during the counts) so I'm not interested in swapping it right now, perhaps later. Besides, I'm thinking with what I have, the supply of MB /CJ-2A starters might be considerably larger. I know, pricing law of supply and demand doesn't have to make sense in this hobby.....just daydreaming.
Right now, I'm thinking I need a solid, reliable, rebuilt MZ-4113, and hope I can get a core charge for this Baby Ruth. There's no old-school starter shops near me.......can anybody recommend a good shop in your neck of the woods?
As always, your comments and advice are appreciated!

Ron D.
1951 M38 Unknown Serial Number
1951 M100 Dunbar Kapple 01169903 dod 5-51
“The only good sports car that America ever made was the Jeep."
--- Enzo Ferrari